Close Up the Little Hole When Knitting Heels in Socks

Whether you’re knitting your very first pair of socks or you’re an experienced knitter with dozens of pairs under your belt, you’ve likely run into the same frustrating issue: a little hole forming where the heel meets the rest of the sock. This tiny gap can appear in all types of heel constructions—peasant heels, heel flap and gusset, and short row heels—and while it’s a minor flaw, it can be annoying and even affect the wearability of the sock over time.

The good news is that this problem is entirely solvable. In fact, with a few strategic adjustments and a bit of knowledge about why it happens, you can avoid it altogether or fix it neatly after the fact. This guide will walk you through everything you need to know about how to close up the little hole when knitting heels—whatever heel style you prefer.

[ez-toc]

Understanding the Causes of Heel Holes

To close the gap effectively, you first need to know why it forms. The “heel hole” is typically the result of structural stress and stitch imbalance at transition points—especially where the heel joins the leg or foot. The most common causes include:

• Loose stitches at the turning point: Heel shaping often involves short rows or sudden directional changes, which can leave small gaps if tension isn’t managed.
• Gaps from picked-up stitches: When picking up stitches along the edge of a heel flap or for an afterthought heel, gaps can form if the stitches aren’t snug or are picked up unevenly.
• Tension inconsistencies: Switching between working in the round and turning rows can create slight differences in tension that show up as holes.
• Structural stress points: The junction where different parts of the sock meet—especially in peasant or gusseted heels—naturally bears more wear, and if not reinforced, these areas can gape.

Understanding where and why these gaps appear makes it much easier to tackle them proactively in your knitting.

Peasant (Afterthought) Heels: Closing the Gap

Peasant heels, also known as Afterthought heels, are popular because they allow the sock to be knit in a tube before the heel is added in later. While convenient, they are especially prone to holes at the corners where the heel is rejoined.

Why holes happen in peasant heels

The issue usually arises at the corners where you pick up stitches around the heel opening. These four points (often referred to as the “corners” of the heel box) are natural stress spots, and if the stitches aren’t snug or reinforced, gaps form easily.

Reinforcement tips before cutting the yarn

One preventative method is to reinforce the area before you even snip your waste yarn. After placing the heel stitches on needles, examine the sides of the heel opening and secure any potentially loose stitches with locking stitch markers or waste yarn.

Closing the hole with a duplicate stitch

If the hole has already formed, a duplicate stitch using the tail yarn or matching sock yarn can fill the gap seamlessly. This is a particularly useful technique when the hole is minor and you want an invisible fix.

Picking up extra stitches around the corner

Try picking up one or two extra stitches in the “gap” area when knitting the first round of the heel. You can decrease them away in the next round by knitting them together with a neighbouring stitch.

Using the tail to graft and secure loose stitches

Leave a long enough tail when you begin the heel so you can go back and sew the hole closed after the heel is finished. Thread the tail through a tapestry needle and graft the loose stitches using duplicate stitch or a whipstitch for strength.

Heel Flap and Gusset Heels: Fixing Holes

Heel flap and gusset constructions are a favourite among sock knitters for their excellent fit and durability. However, holes often occur at the corner where the gusset stitches are picked up.

Common gap areas at the gusset pick-up

Gaps tend to appear where the heel flap transitions into the gusset. This corner bears extra tension and is often where the hole forms.

The “pick up one more” technique

A tried-and-true method is to pick up one extra stitch at each corner when working up the gusset. Then, knit it together with the next stitch on the following row to tighten the join.

Twisting stitches when picking up

When picking up along the heel flap, try picking up the bar between stitches and twisting it (knit through the back loop). This adds stability and reduces the likelihood of a hole forming.

Tightening holes with the working yarn

After picking up stitches and working a few rounds, check the corner areas. If gaps remain, you can use the working yarn to weave through the loose strands and snug them up before weaving in the tail.

Weaving in ends to close gaps permanently

The tail of your yarn can do double-duty here. After the gusset is complete, use it to sew any holes shut with a darning needle—working through nearby purl bumps or the inside fabric layer to make it nearly invisible.

Short Row Heels: Solving Holes

Short row heels offer a clean, uninterrupted line in the sock’s fabric and are often praised for their simplicity. However, holes at the turning points can be an issue if not carefully managed. Another common trouble spot with short row heels is the top corners—right where the heel ends rejoin the rest of the sock. These areas are under tension and frequently stretch open during wear.

Why wrap-and-turn can cause gaps

Traditional wrap-and-turn methods can leave a visible hole if the wrap isn’t snugly hidden. Gaps can appear on both sides of the heel where the short rows turn.

German short row technique to avoid holes

The German short row method is a fantastic alternative that often results in fewer gaps. It involves pulling the yarn up and over the needle to create a “double stitch,” which is worked as one stitch in the following row.

Picking up wraps correctly

If you’re using wrap-and-turns, be sure to pick up the wraps correctly when knitting them in. Failing to do so can leave a visible hole. Always lift the wrap onto the left needle and knit it together with the stitch.

Closing remaining holes with mattress stitch or whipstitch

For stubborn gaps, mattress stitch from the inside of the sock can neatly cinch the hole closed. Alternatively, whipstitch around the loosened stitches using a matching yarn tail.

Preventing and Fixing Corner Holes in Short Row Heels

To prevent or close these gaps:

• Pick up an extra stitch at each corner when resuming work on the round. Insert your needle into the gap between the heel and instep stitches, lift the strand, and knit it together with the next stitch. This neatly pulls the edges together without adding bulk.

• Tighten with the yarn tail: Leave a long tail when starting your heel, and after finishing the sock, use that tail to sew the hole closed with a whipstitch or duplicate stitch, blending it into the fabric.

• Use German short rows with a slipped stitch edge: If working flat before returning to the round, slipping the first stitch of every row creates a clean edge that is easier to pick up tightly later on.

General Techniques to Prevent Heel Holes

Preventing the hole is always easier than fixing it after the fact. Here are some universal techniques:

• Adjust tension deliberately: Tighten your tension slightly when transitioning between heel and foot stitches.
• Pick up a stitch in the “gap”: Then knit it together with the next stitch. This closes the hole while keeping your stitch count even.
• Use knit through the back loop (k-tbl): It tightens the picked-up stitches and reduces looseness.
• Place a stitch marker: Use markers to track common problem spots and remember to reinforce them later.

Repairing Holes After the Fact

Even with the best planning, sometimes a heel hole appears. Here’s how to fix it neatly:

• Duplicate stitch method: Ideal for small holes and maintaining the sock’s look.
• Invisible weaving techniques: Use a fine darning needle to draw the tail through nearby stitches, closing the gap.
• Reinforce vs. redo: If the hole is large or structural, it might be worth unpicking a few rows and re-knitting the section.

Tips for Neat Finishing on All Heel Types

A neat finish can make your socks look polished and feel stronger:

• Leave long tails when starting heels to give yourself options for reinforcement.
• Use a smaller needle to snug up any loose stitches after knitting.
• Always check the heel join before binding off or sewing up.

Recommended Tools and Materials

Having the right tools to hand makes fixing holes easier:

• Tapestry or darning needle
• A smaller knitting needle for tightening loose stitches
• Locking stitch markers
• Yarn with a bit of stretch (like wool or nylon blend)

FAQs About Fixing Holes in Knitted Sock Heels

Why does my heel always have a hole no matter what?
It’s often due to loose tension or missed stitches when picking up at heel joins. Reinforcement and picking up an extra stitch can help.

Can I reinforce the area before it becomes a hole?
Yes, using tighter tension, extra pick-ups, or even duplicate stitch before wear can prevent holes.

What is the best heel type for avoiding holes?
Short row heels using the German method tend to produce fewer holes, but any heel can be hole-free with the right techniques.

Should I change my needle size near heel joins?
Some knitters go down a quarter size to snug up the area. It’s optional but worth trying if you get persistent gaps.

Can I fix a heel hole after washing the socks?
Yes, though it may be trickier. Use matching yarn and sew carefully through the stitches without pulling too tightly.

How tight should my tension be near the gusset?
Slightly tighter than average—enough to close gaps, but not so much that the fabric pulls or puckers.

Are there pre-emptive patterns or stitches that help?
Yes, many sock patterns include extra gusset or heel reinforcement. Look for patterns with specific instructions for gap-free joins.

Conclusion

Heel holes are one of the most common quirks of sock knitting, but they’re also one of the easiest to fix—once you know how. Whether you’re working a peasant heel, a gusseted heel flap, or a short row design, the key lies in strategic reinforcement, careful stitch pick-up, and smart finishing. With a little practice and the techniques shared in this guide, you’ll soon be knitting seamless, strong, and hole-free socks that look as good as they feel.

Need more sock knitting resources? Check out our sock hub.